50 Underrated Singles of Popular Artists
Whenever a popular artist releases an album, they are bound to have at least one or two hit singles, but for every hit, there are a couple that do not chart as well. A lot of times, I find those songs to be some of the more interesting releases from an artist (although I am not suggesting that the popular songs aren’t worthy, and some of them are still my favorite song from them). Sometimes, I don’t understand why they are not as beloved as their biggest hits while there are times where I understand why (maybe too sad or slow to be radio friendly), but they are beautiful songs that deserve to be recognized, nonetheless. The point of this article is to highlight some of my favorite songs that get overshadowed by the giant hits.
Here are my criteria: I defined a single a couple of different ways: 1, the song has their own Wikipedia page or is listed as a single on the Wikipedia page for an album or 2, you can buy it as a single on iTunes or 3, in absence of criteria 1 or 2, there is a sponsored or lyric music video on the official YouTube channel of the artist. Admittedly, I did not conduct in-depth research on how the single charted, it is based more on my perceived popularity of the song (how often I hear the song on the radio compared to other singles, how often the single is covered online or on televised talent shows, etc.). OK, there are 50 of these, so let’s get started!
Adele: “Send My Love”
Adele’s album 25 had one giant hit, and that was “Hello”. To be honest, I personally don’t love that song. What’s nice about this song is that it’s one of very few bouncy and kinda happy songs that she sings, and it highlights her being in a mature headspace where she can finally move on from the man who broke her heart.
Christina Aguilera: “Ain’t No Other Man”
I’m one of very few fans who loved Christina’s foray into jazz on her album Back to Basics. That being said, I do agree with the review of the album from Rolling Stone which basically said if she had cut out half of the songs and brought it down from two discs to one it would’ve been as monumental as Amy Winehouse’s Back to Black (although Stripped is also two discs and is much more popular; Christina really needs to learn how to self-edit). I really love “Candyman” and considered choosing that for this list, but I think it’s the first song people think of when referring to this particular album. This song strikes the best balance between jazz and pop with its blaring horns combined with modern production and her signature R&B vocal styling. Honestly, this was the type of music I was hoping Gwen Stefani would do when she went solo.
Fiona Apple: “Never Is a Promise”
As a huge fan, there were many songs I could have picked for Fiona. A couple of years ago, I would’ve picked “Paper Bag”, but Rolling Stone named it one of the 500 best songs ever, so it must not be that obscure. Most of Fiona’s songs tend to be angry, but this song is just achingly gorgeous. The strings and piano are classically beautiful, and this is one of only a couple of songs where she uses her upper vocal range.
Sara Bareilles: “Armor”
Sara has had some great hits, but there are many others that are really clever or poignant that do not get as much recognition. Her album Amidst the Chaos was conceived in the wake of Donald Trump winning the presidency as a rallying cry to fight against his misogyny and a beacon of hope that reason will one day prevail. The centerpiece of the album and its lead single was written in support of the MeToo movement and was released early in light of Brett Kavanaugh’s confirmation to the Supreme Court. It starts with Sara asking, “How did Eve get all the damn blame?” for Original Sin and goes on to sing the praises of women who support other women in the face of oppression.
Barenaked Ladies: “Alcohol”
I didn’t even realize this song was released as a single; they did not even play it at the concert I went to recently. This witty song extols the virtues of alcoholism but in the process highlights the negative social and mental effects of the disease.
Courtney Barnett: “Three Packs a Day”
It may be a bit debatable whether Courtney’s a “popular” artist; she’s not top 40 material, but she seems to do well on the rock charts, and she was nominated at the Grammys for Best New Artist. This quaint but funny song is about a bad habit of hers, but it’s not what you think…
The Beatles: “The Fool on the Hill”
I remember once reading an article reviewing an American Idol episode which included the contestants singing a group medley of Beatles songs. When the singers got to this song (which is admittedly a weird choice for a group medley), the author of the article didn’t know it, and I felt sad for him. Written by Paul McCartney, it tells the story of an isolated and misunderstood man who thinks on a different level than everyone else. The message I get from the song is that people are afraid of anyone or anything they don’t understand.
Beyoncé: “Naughty Girl”
I remember hearing this song a decent amount on the radio when it first came out, but Beyoncé has had such an illustrious career that it has almost ended up forgotten. It’s a shame because the composition of the song is unique (I personally think it’s better conceived than “Run the World”. Yeah, the latter song may have a more empowering message (although its bridge kinda undermines it), but it’s repetitive as hell, bordering on annoying). Using an interpolation of (and improving upon) Donna Summer’s “Love to Love You Baby”, the arrangement is a mixture of R&B, funk, and Middle Eastern music. Beyoncé goes from whispery falsetto to playing with the seductive minor key, all the while singing backup for herself.
Kelly Clarkson: “Sober”
“Since You Been Gone” is deservedly Kelly’s biggest hit, but I just love this song. The album this song is from, My December, is also pretty underrated; after she left 19 Records, it gave her the freedom to experiment with different moods and genres. I understand a song like this (an almost 5-minute-long emotional ballad) isn’t exactly radio friendly, but other personal ballads of hers (“Because of You” and “Piece by Piece”) have been hugely successful and covered many times despite being specifically about Kelly’s childhood family issues. She has been more tightlipped about what “Sober” is about; despite the title, I tend to interpret it as experiencing a loss of some sort rather than addiction and the rough road of recovery: “Three months and it’s still harder now. Three months and I’ve been living here without you now”. As the song slowly builds from just acoustic guitar to a full orchestra, Kelly’s emotion crescendos as the strings swell leading to a cathartic outburst, which almost never fails to make me cry.
The Doobie Brothers: “Black Water”
I’m not sure how popular this song was when it was released, but the radio plays, covers, or karaoke I hear nowadays consist of “Takin’ It to the Streets”, “Long Train Runnin’”, “China Grove”, and “Listen to the Music”. What makes this song stand out from those hits is its classically soulful folk sound, and it’s not every day that you hear a song with an a cappella breakdown midway through.
Billie Eilish: “Oxytocin”
OK, I partially like this song because oxytocin is my favorite hormone (yes, I’m that nerdy); it’s released by the brain to promote bonding during birth, breastfeeding, and, most notably, during orgasm. Billie tells a pursuer that God wouldn’t approve of what they’d do because “She couldn't look away…She'd wanna get involved”, and the intensity of the electronic arrangement ramps up as she says “I wanna do bad things to you…You should really run away”. Hilariously, the official music video is sponsored by Disney (maybe they couldn’t understand what she’s saying?).
Florence + the Machine: “Rabbit Heart”
If I were to pick a song to introduce Florence’s writing style, it would be this song; an orchestral pop song full of literary and mythological allusions with the harp as a leading instrument despite it not being a ballad. It also greatly showcases her vocal chops (she’s the entire choir).
The Goo Goo Dolls: “Broadway”
“Iris” and “Slide” are their most popular songs, and I really like them, but this song probably has the best lyrics. It’s a character study of a man whose had the real world crush his motivation in life: “See the young man sittin’ in the old man’s bar, waiting for his turn to die”.
Ariana Grande “Dangerous Woman”
It could very well be that I just wasn’t paying attention to top 40 radio when this song was released (I’m a little older than Ariana’s target demographic), but it doesn’t seem to be as popular as “Thank You, Next”, “7 Rings”, or “Bang Bang”. I certainly think it’s a better song than “Side to Side” in the sexual song competition. While the rhythm of the song and her vocals are reminiscent of a ‘90s sexy R&B jam, the rock guitar work imbues it with just enough edge to make it feel, well, dangerous.
Huey Lewis & the News: “Walking on a Thin Line”
Huey’s mostly known for lighthearted fare such as “I Want a New Drug”, “Do You Believe in Love?”, and “Hip to Be Square”. This song is one of their more serious ones, highlighting how we revere war veterans but don’t help them in the long run.
Imagine Dragons: “On Top of the World”
I have to hand it to Imagine Dragons; they have a zillion hits on the radio, and none of them sound alike. I don’t hear this one on the radio as much as “Radioactive”, “Believer”, “I Bet My Life”, or their newer ones. I first heard this song as the theme song to a terrible sitcom called Partners that only lasted seven episodes. This is probably their cheeriest sounding song, with the handclaps and the guitar work that almost sounds like whistling.
Billy Joel: “The Stranger”
“Piano Man”, “New York State of Mind”, “Only the Good Die Young”, “Uptown Girl”, “The Longest Time”, and, unfortunately, “We Didn’t Start the Fire” are some of Billy’s most well-known songs. The title track from one of my favorite albums ever, this song starts and ends with some piano and whistling reminiscent of a film noir, which fits the message of the song: we all have an inner world or self that we never reveal to other people, even people we love and care about.
Norah Jones: “Miriam”
“Miriam, that’s such a pretty name…” Norah creepily sings as she tells her man’s mistress her intentions to kill her. Yes, Norah freaking Jones, whose music is made for gently putting your parents to sleep, wrote a cold-blooded murder song! Who knew she had it in her? Her album, …Little Broken Hearts, is really underrated; it was a great move hiring Danger Mouse to produce it, allowing her to broaden her range musically and thematically.
Jukebox the Ghost: “Hollywood”
Here’s another artist where I may be stretching the term “popular”, but I’ve heard “Everybody’s Lonely” and “Fred Astaire” on alternative radio stations quite a bit. It’s rare to find a catchy song with such drastic changes in tempo, and its lyrics dismantling romantic love as it’s portrayed in movies and other pop songs are refreshing.
Alicia Keys: “Karma”
I just love the hip-hop style of the violin in this song, and most of Alicia’s popular songs (except for maybe “Fallin’”) are more akin to the modern R&B typically heard on the radio today; she doesn’t get enough credit for her creativity.
Kendrick Lamar: “For Free?”
It’s not every day that you hear vulgar spoken-word jazz. I love it.
Adam Lambert: “Trespassing”
Adam’s probably more known for finishing runner up on American Idol than anything, although he did have one pretty big hit, the P!nk-penned “Whataya Want from Me?”, which indulged in his melodramatic tendencies. This song is a lot more fun; the stomping beat during the chorus is somewhat reminiscent of “We Will Rock You” while the funky bassline turns it into a rock disco.
Miranda Lambert: “Way Too Pretty for Prison” (feat. Maren Morris)
Miranda is a good country-pop singer, but God, I’m sick of people covering “Gunpowder and Lead”! I probably should’ve picked one of her more serious songs since I don’t think I’ve heard any of them covered, but truthfully, I only like country in really small doses, so I don’t listen to country radio and tend to mainly gravitate towards the country songs that make me laugh. In this collaboration with another country-pop powerhouse, they consider killing their boyfriends for cheating but decide not to because you can’t, like, get your nails done in prison! It’s kinda like “Goodbye Earl” if the protagonists were spoiled sociopaths.
Avril Lavigne: “Here’s to Never Growing Up”
I do consider Avril my guilty pleasure, but she is really good at writing songs teens can relate to. I considered choosing one of her more serious songs (like “Nobody’s Home”), but I enjoy listening to her because she has a knack for writing catchy, slightly obnoxious songs. This fun song came out about 10 years after “Complicated” (which was about 10 years ago…geez!), and it seems to fit her as someone about my age (late 30s) whose music hasn’t matured much since she was 16.
Lorde: “Glory and Gore”
“Glory and gore go hand in hand. That’s why we’re making headlines.” I honestly think this song makes more sense for the Hunger Games movies than “Yellow Flicker Beat”. I absolutely love “Royals” like everyone else (those harmonies!), but this is my favorite song of Lorde’s lyrically.
Demi Lovato: “29”
As an adult, Demi has been getting real about living as a Disney star and the struggles they’ve endured as a teen (mental health issues, substance use addiction, and sexual assault). This song concerns the latter, specifically statutory rape. Demi, now 29 years old, allegedly wrote this song about their relationship with Wilmer Valderrama when he was 29 and they were 17.
Macklemore: “Shadow” (feat. IRO)
“Thrift Shop” is fun and amusing, but here is a more serious song for you. It was created on the TV show Songland where songwriters compete for their song to be recorded by a famous artist. I was pleasantly surprised that the hip-hop artist liked the Celtic inspired arrangement, and he added lyrics interpreting the shadow as his alcoholism.
Matchbox Twenty: “Back to Good”
OK, it’s debatable whether this song is “underrated” since most Matchbox Twenty fans really like if not love it, and I’ll admit that this is an excuse to highlight my favorite song from them. Still, the songs I mostly hear on the radio or see in pop culture today are “Unwell”, “Push”, “3AM”, and “How Far We’ve Come”. I love this song because it’s a musical monologue for Rob Thomas; his emotion trembles beneath the surface and just erupts at the end like a volcano. I believe every word.
M.I.A.: “Sunshowers”
M.I.A.’s breakout single “Paper Planes” appeared on her sophomore album Kala, so the great singles from her debut album Arular don’t get much love. She interpolates the chorus from a love song by the big band Dr. Buzzard's Original Savannah Band and makes the lyrics more sinister, all the while rapping about the post 9/11 aggressive pro-war culture perpetuated by Tony Blair and the murder of a young man as a result.
Nicki Minaj: “Barbie Dreams”
Admittedly, the only other songs by Nicki I know are “Super Bass”, “Starships”, and “Anaconda”. This song flips the script on The Notorious B.I.G.’s “Just Playing”, a song where he contemplates which R&B singers he would sleep with, which has some funny lines (“Mariah Carey is scary…”) but also some completely inappropriate lines (references to Tina Turner’s domestic abuse and Raven-Symoné, who was only 8 at the time). Nicki doesn’t hold back on roasting rappers while she relays (I’m pretty sure mostly fictional) sexual exploits she’s experienced with them with some funny lines of her own: “I don't know if the pussy wet or if [Drake is] crying and shit”
Alanis Morrisette: “Uninvited”
Alanis has probably had the most influence on today’s female pop-rock singers. “You Oughta Know” is the most epic of angry break-up songs while “Ironic” and “Hand in My Pocket” are also popular. This song doesn’t seem to get as much airplay as those hits from her quintessential album Jagged Little Pill. I sometimes just love a haunting song with a dramatic string arrangement.
Jason Mraz: “Geek in the Pink”
Before Ed Sheeran was mixing urban pop in with his acoustic balladry, Jason was doing it replete with witty double entendres (“Well, I can save you from unoriginal dum-dums who wouldn't care if you com…plete them or not”). I was going to pick “You and I Both”, but I highlighted it in my music videos article, and most people who associate him with “I’m Yours” and his more recent granola hippie persona would be surprised by this song.
Kacey Musgraves: “Blowin’ Smoke”
I like Kacey because her lyrics are witty and poignant, and she doesn’t romanticize small-town America like some of her contemporaries. Her big hits from her acclaimed debut album Same Trailer, Different Park were “Follow Your Arrow” and “Merry-Go-Round”, and this clever song unfortunately didn’t garner as much attention. Country is made for telling stories; here, she’s a diner waitress on her smoking break recounting the pathetic lives of her coworkers, and she makes great use of double meanings (including the title): “We all say that we’ll quit someday” could refer to smoking or their dead-end jobs.
The Offspring: “She’s Got Issues”
As far as The Offspring’s more fun songs go, “Pretty Fly for a White Guy” and “Why Don’t You Get a Job?” are probably their most popular. This amusing song recounts the trials and tribulations of dating someone who hasn’t dealt with her past and doesn’t have her shit together: “You told me a hundred times how your father left, and he's gone, but I wish you wouldn't call me daddy when we're gettin' it on”.
Of Monsters and Men: “Love Love Love”
I love “Little Talks” and “Mountain Sound”, but I find this to be their most relatable song. Nanna Bryndís Hilmarsdóttir captures the feeling of guilt when you aren’t as into a romantic relationship as your partner is. It’s the other person’s side in “I Can’t Make You Love Me”.
Outkast: “B.O.B.”
I tend to hear “Hey Ya!” and “Ms. Jackson” on the radio the most. What I like about Outkast is that they don’t sound like anyone else. A beat reminiscent of a machine gun, Andre 3000 and Big Boi rapping a million miles an hour, gospel backing vocals, and a shredding guitar solo make up their most interesting and unique single.
Pearl Jam: “Sirens”
I know this is probably blasphemy, but I think I prefer Pearl Jam’s newer stuff over their classics from the ‘90s; they seem to be more willing to explore different sounds as they get older (and you can actually understand most of what Eddie Vedder is saying!). This powerful rock ballad ruminates on mortality in the context of a romantic relationship.
Queen: “Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy”
A delightfully flirty openly gay love song from the ‘70s? Yes, please!
Bonnie Raitt: “Thing Called Love”
It’s a strange paradox that the album Nick of Time was Bonnie’s breakout into the mainstream, yet I almost never hear any of the songs from it on the radio or TV (whereas I’ve lost count of the number of whiny covers of “I Can’t Make You Love Me” I’ve heard). The percussion and bass line of this song compliment Bonnie’s masterful guitar sliding, and she’s self-assured in her sexuality.
The Rolling Stones: “Tumbling Dice”
This is in Rolling Stone magazine’s 500 Best Songs Ever (and within the top 100 to boot), so I could just have been living under a rock, but neither my dad (who was actually around during the ‘70s and is my main source of classic rock knowledge) nor I had heard this song until last year. I really like the bluesy guitar and soulful backing vocals of this song.
Emeli Sandé: “Heaven”
“I wake with good intentions, but the day, it always lasts too long.” One of the greatest lyrics on human failing I’ve ever heard.
Ed Sheeran: “Small Bump”
At risk of spoiling this song, I was surprised it was released as a single because it’s a gut punch at the end. Most of Ed’s hits are pretty lighthearted, and I think we’ve all gotten to the point where we forget that his first major hit, “The A Team”, was about coke-addicted prostitutes. I kinda miss his deeper songs.
The Shins: “Fighting in a Sack”
The Shins are the kings of modern pretentious indie bands; “New Slang” and “Caring Is Creepy” were featured in Garden State (Natalie Portman’s character claims those songs will change your life. I like them, but yeah, right!), and “So Says I” was featured on Gilmore Girls. This song is deceptively fun to listen to; the fast tempo of the vocals, acoustic guitar, and harmonica solo actually make me picture cartoon characters going nuts in a bag. However, it’s a fairly pessimistic song: “Most ideas turn to dust, and there are few in which we all can trust. Haven't you noticed I've been shedding all of mine?”
Soundgarden: “The Day I Tried to Live”
The dissonance from the unorthodox tuning of the guitars gives this song an uneasy feeling, and the unusual time signature (one measure of 7/4, then two of 4/4) and Red Hot Chili Peppers-esque bassline make it stand out from the typical grunge songs offered by other bands, and Chris Cornell’s vocals are on full display, going deep in the verses and full throttle in the chorus. The lyrics depict his struggle with socializing during his depression. Note: I may be overly cautious here, but I chose to not post the official music video because it depicts someone wrapping cords around his neck while hanging from the ceiling, and it might not be tasteful considering how Chris eventually died.
Spice Girls: “Mama”
This is a sweet song, and it depicts how growing up can change your perspective on how you were raised.
Harry Styles: “Kiwi”
Catchy pops songs (“Watermelon Sugar”, “As It Was”) and ballads (“Sign of the Times”) from Harry’s repertoire seem to dominate the radio, which is a shame because he can apparently really rock out.
Taylor Swift: “No Body, No Crime” (feat. HAIM)
Evermore is an underrated album; it really highlights Taylor’s storytelling prowess (although I understand the lack of fanfare; Folklore came out mere months before and just blew everyone away). In this song, her friend goes missing, and she suspects her unfaithful husband but frustratingly doesn’t have any proof.
SZA: “Drew Barrymore”
“The Weekend” is the most popular song from SZA’s critically acclaimed debut album Ctrl, but I prefer this song. SZA is best when she lets herself be vulnerable, and she bares her insecurities to her man in this song. I also like the strings at the end.
KT Tunstall: “Other Side of the World”
KT’s debut album Eye to the Telescope is fantastic, and I was pleasantly surprised that an interesting and artistic song like “Black Horse and the Cherry Tree” was such a big hit (“Suddenly I See” is great too, just more radio friendly), but this song is just as deserving. Here she laments how she is slowly growing apart from her partner.
Wilson Phillips: “Release Me”
Of course, I love “Hold On”, but I grew up listening to them and have a soft spot for their music. When you have a group consisting of the daughters of Brian Wilson from The Beach Boys and John and Michelle Phillips of The Mamas & the Papas, you know harmonizing must be their strength, and this song is the prime example.